VOLUME 3

AN ANSWERE VNTO SIR THOMAS MORES DIALOGE

LOCATION
KEY Commentary Side Textual Bibliographic Scriptural

and thinke that god for soch seruyce as they doo to images / will fulfill their worldly desyres: for godly can they nought desyre. Now God is a spirite and wilbe worsheped in his worde only which is spirituall / and wil haue no bodylye seruice. And the ceremonies of the olde law he set vpp / to signifie his worde only and to kepe the people in minde of his testament. So that he which obserueth any ceremonie of any other purpose is an Idolater / that is / an imageseruer.

173/16–24 the faith . . . holy church. Tyndale expresses Luther's doctrine of the primacy of the word of promise and of faith in sacraments. But specific themes of Luther's sacramental instruction of 1519–24 are missing, such as the testamentary character of the promise in the Lord's Supper, the content as forgiveness of sins, and the addressee as the troubled and terrified conscience, cf. 63/31n. (JW)

Ezechias 1531

JOHN: 4.24: 63/15–16, 84/6, 88/7–8,88/32–33, 108/3,124/17–18

173/17–22 And the sacrament ... at all. Cf. CWM 8/1.95/23–26.

And when he saith / if men axe wemen whether it were oure lady of walsingam or Ipsewich that was saluted of Gabriel or that stode by Christ when he henge on the crosse / they will saye nether nother. Then I axe him what meaneth it / that they saye oure lady of walsynggam praye for me oure lady of Ipswich praye for me our lady of wilsdon praye for me / in so moch that some which reken them selues no small foles / make them roules of halfe an houre longe / to praye aftir that maner. And they that so praye / thou maist besure / meane oure lady that stode by the crosse / and hir that was saluted therto.

173/25–26 He teacheth . . . werkes. Cf. CWM 6/1.352/27–28 and Rom. 3.28. Cf. CWM 6/2.700 for references to Luther's sources.

henge] hung 1573

173/26–174/29 the scripture ... no beleffe. Here Tyndale explains Luther's teaching on how good works are consequent upon the forgiveness of sins, for example, as expounded in The Freedom of a Christian, 1520 (WA 7.25/26–26/31, 29/31–34/22; LW 31.351–53, 358–65). Later, in the Augsburg Confession of 1530, in a passage Tyndale apparently did not know, Lutherans claimed to be untiring teachers of good works, as evidenced by Luther's Treatise on Good Works, 1520 (WA 6.202–76; LW 44.21–114) and his catechetical expositions of the commandments. Cf. Art. 20 of the Confession , The Book of Concord 41–46. (JW)

173/26–28 assone . . . imediatly. Cf. Rom. 3.23–25.

Then he reherseth many abuses / and how wemen singe songes of ribaudrie in processions in cathedrall churches. Vn to which abhominacions yet our holy church that can not erre / consent with full delectacion. For on the on syde they will not amend the abuse. And on the other syde they haue hired M. More to proue with his sophistrie / that the thynges ought not to be put doune.

how] how that 1573

Processions 1531

174/1–3 For . . . god. Cf. CWM 8/1.326/14–16, 402/12–14. Tyndale refers to Bk. 4, not Bk. 3 as More mistakenly says.

174/3–5 But ... by fayth. Cf. Rom. 3.8.

Then he bringeth in how the wild Irish and the welch praye / when they goo to stele. And ax

174/7 He calleth . . .werkes. Cf. CWM 6/1.352/28–29.