VOLUME 3

AN ANSWERE VNTO SIR THOMAS MORES DIALOGE

LOCATION
KEY Commentary Side Textual Bibliographic Scriptural

ny as were nedefull. So that what soeuer we ought to beleue or doo / that same is written expresly or drawen out of that which is written.

24/25–30 the pith . . . written. Cf. CWM 8/1.258/12–14.

24/28–30 So . . . written. CWM 8/1.258/14–16.

For if I were bounde to doo or beleue vnder payne of the losse of my soule any thynge that were not written / ner depended of that which is written / what holpe me the scripture that is written? And therto in as moch as Christ and all his apostles warned vs that false prophetes shuld come with false miracles / even to disceaue the electe / if it were possible / where with shuld the true preacher confounde the false / excepte he brought true miracles to confounde the false or else autentycke scripture of full auctorite all ready amonge the people.

not] om. 1573

24/31–25/1 For if . . . that is written. Cf. CWM 8/1.263/11–13.

25/2–4 false . . . possible. Cf. Matt. 24.24, Mark 13.22.

Matt. 24.24, Mark 13.22: 25/2–4, 89/25–26, 99/30–32, 100/6, 101/9–12, 129/27

25/2–7 in as moch . . . people. CWM 8/1.264/28–33.

Some man wolde axe / how did god continue his congregacion from Adam to Noe / & from Noe to Abraham / and so to Moses / with out wrytynge / but with teachynge from mouth to mouth. I answere first that there was no scripture all the while / they shall proue / when oure lady hath a new sonne. God taught Adam greater thinges then to write. And that there was writynge in the world longe yer Abraham ye and yer Noe doo stories testifie.

25/8–12 Some man . . . sonne. Cf. CWM 8/1.271/34–272/3.

25/12–13 God . . . write. CWM 8/1.273/36.

25/13–14 And that . . . testifie. CWM 8/1.274/8–9.

Notwithstondinge / though there had bene no writynge / the preachers were euer prophetes glorious in doynge of miracles / where with they confirmed their preachynge. And beyonde that god wrote his testament vn to them all waye / both what to doo and to beleue / even in sacramentes. For the sacrifices which god gaue Adams sonnes were no dumme popetrie or supersticious

25/15–17 Notwithstondinge . . . preachynge. CWM 8/1.274/22—24.

sacramentes] the sacramentes 1573

25/20 popetrie. Cf. Obedience G5v, Matthew k2v. Tyndale refers to religious ceremonies and scriptural glosses as other examples of false "poetry" (1 John A6v). Tyndale rebuked his former assistant William Roye for discrediting the reformers' cause by using "raylinge rymes" (Mammon A3) against Wolsey in Barlowe and Roye. A sidenote on Gen. 47 views poetry as the ivy that strangles the tree of truth (Mombert 143; TOT 76). Cf. Peter C. Herman, Squitter-Wits and Muse-Haters: Sidney, Spenser, Milton and Antipoetic Sentiment (Detroit:Wayne State UP, 1996) 34–43, esp. 41.

GENESIS: 47: 25/20