VOLUME 3

AN ANSWERE VNTO SIR THOMAS MORES DIALOGE

LOCATION
KEY Commentary Side Textual Bibliographic Scriptural

thoughtes. For though they saw him reyse vpp other / yet who shulde reyse hym vpp / when he were deed / they coude not comprehende.

85/3–4 Morouer . . . Egypte. Cf. Exod. 12.40–42. Tyndale treats the Exodus as a literal escape from Egypt, not as an allegorical escape from sin.

Reade what thou reade canst / and thou shalt fynd no temptacyon lyke vnto that from the creacyon of the world / or so greate as yt by the hundred parte. So that the wonderfull soden chaunge and the tereble syght of hys passyon and of hys most cruell and most vile deeth / and the losse of whom they so greatly loued / that theyr hertes wolde fayne haue died wyth hym / and the feare of their awne deeth / and the impossibilite that a man shulde ryse agayne of his awne power / so occupyed theyr myndes and so astonyed them and amased them / that they coude receaue no comforte / ether of the scrypture or of the miracles which they had sene christ doo / nor of the monicions and warnynge wherewith he had warned them before / nether of the women that brought them tydynges that he was rysen. The swerd of temptacyons wyth feare / sorow / mornynge & wepynge / had depely perced theyr hertes / and the cruell syght. had so combred their mindes / that they coude not beleue / vntyll chryst hym selfe came / deeth put off and ouercome / ye and when they first saw him / they were astonied for wonderinge and ioye to gether that thoughtes a rose in theyr hertes / alas ys thys he or doeth some spirite mocke vs? he was faine to lett them feale him and to eate with them / to strength theyr faythes.

85/7 holy straunge gestures. CWM 6/1.56/4.

85/11 left . . . tyme. Cf. CWM 6/1.56/6–7. Tyndale omits More's qualifying phrase, "greate parte wherof" (CWM 6/1.56/6).

85/12 For . . . did. Cf. 1 Cor. 11.23–26.

Matt. 9.18–19,23–26; Mark 5.21–24, 35–43; Luke 8.40–42, 49–56: 36/14

LUKE: 7.12–15: 36/14

JOHN: 11.11–44: 36/14

85/14–15 Paule . . . nothinge. Cf. Acts 20.27.

warnynge] warnings 1573

Matt. 28.8, Mark 16.10–11, Luke 24.8–11: 36/16–17

85/17–18 moare . . . with out it. Cf. CWM 6/1.56/23–24.

feare /] ed., feare 1531, 1573

LUKE: 24.36–43: 36/20–24

85/20–22 And at the sight . . . deed. Tyndale voices a common 16c critique of the emphasis on compassion with the suffering Christ in late medieval piety. Erasmus had warned against a merely natural pity for Christ's sufferings in the Seventeenth Rule of the Enchiridion, 1503 (Holborn 117/12–13; CWE 66.110). Luther was also critical of this form of affective participation in the passion of Jesus in Freedom of a Christian, 1520 (WA 7.29/11–13; LW 31.357). Cf. "Passion (mystique de la)" in Dictionnaire de Spiritualité, ed. Marcel Viller SJ et al., 17 vols. including Index (Paris: Beauchesne, 1937–95) 12.329–32; F.Vandenbroucke, "La devotion au Crucifié à la fin du moyen âge," Maison Dieu, no. 75 (1963) 133–43. (JW)

How be yt there was none of them that was fallen in hys hert from chryste. For assone as the wemen brought worde / Peter and Ihon ran vnto the sepulchre and saw and wondred and wold fayne haue beleuen that he was

JOHN: 20.3–9: 36/26–28

85/27 prayenge at church. Cf. CWM 6/1.57/34–36.

wondred] 1573, wonred [1531]

JOHN: 20.1–2: 36/28–30

beleuen] beleued 1573; risen] 1573, rosen [1531]