VOLUME 3

AN ANSWERE VNTO SIR THOMAS MORES DIALOGE

LOCATION
KEY Commentary Side Textual Bibliographic Scriptural

postles and prophetes and all the scripture / with signes and miracles / and al the bloud of marters. And who soever goeth vnto God and vnto forgeuenesse of synnes or saluacion / by any other waye then thys / the same is an heretike out of the rightwaye and not of Christes church.

There is no way to saluation, but by Christes death and passion.[[1573]

And Christ . . . church. Cf. CWM 8/1.410/35–411/9.

that . . . church. Repeated at CWM 8/1.414/22–28.

who soever . . . church. Cf. CWM 8/1.417/4–6. Here and in the Prologue to Hebrews (Wallis 502/4–6;TNT 347), Tyndale accuses Roman Catholics of an unspecified heresy, namely Pelagianism. Pelagius (c354—c419) taught that Adam's sin affected only himself, that all humans are born in a state of grace and that Christ functions only as model. Later, Semi-Pelagianism taught that humans could make an initial act of faith without the help of grace. Both heresies were opposed by numerous writings of Augustine . Pelagianism was condemned by the ecumenical Council of Ephesus in 431; Semi-Pelagianism, by the provincial Council of Orange II in 529 (NCE 11.58–60; OER 3.238–41).

For this knowlege maketh a man of the church. And the church is christes body Collossen. j. and every person of the church is a member of christ. Ephe. 5. Now it is no member of christ that hath not christes spirite in it. Roma. viij. as it is no parte of me or member of my body wherin my soule is not present and quikeneth it. And then iff a man be none of christes / he is not of his church.

the church is christes body. Cf. Col. 1.18.

Colossians 1.18

Col. j. [1531]

every . . . christ. Eph. 5.29–30.

Ephesians 5.29–30

Ephe. 5. [1531]

Now ... in it. Cf. Rom. 8.9.

Romans 8.9

Rom. 8. [1531]

And the church . . . church. Cf. CWM 8/1.418/2–6.

¶How a true member of christes church synneth not / and how he is yet a synner

¶ How . . . synner. Cf. CWM 8/1.419/17–18.

Furthermoare / he that hath this faith can not sinne / and therfore can not be disceaved with damnable erroures. For by this faith we be (as I saide) borne of God. Now he that is born of god can not synne / for his seed dwelleth in him / and he can not therfore synne / because he is born of God .j. Ihon .iij. which seed is the holygost that kepith a mans hert from consentinge vnto sinne. And therfore it is a false conclusion that master More holdeth / how that a man maye haue a righte faith ioyned with all kyndes of abhominacion and synne.

Furthermoare . . . erroures. Cf. CWM 8/1.421/2–3.

Now . . . God. 1 John 3.9.

1 John 3.9

j. Ioha. 3. [1531]

For ... synne. Cf. CWM 8/1.421/12–18. Confutation quotes Answer's older verb form "kepith" [C1] at CWM 8/1.420/3 but gives the newer form "kepys" at CWM 8/1.421/ 15.

And therfore . . . synne. Cf. CWM 8/1.459/27–29.

Faith and synne can not stond to gether. [1531]

And yet every membir of Christes congregacion is a synner and sinneth dayly / some moare and some lesse. For it is written .j. Ihon .j. if we saye we haue no synne / we disceaue oure selues and the trueth is not in vs. And agayne iff we saye / we haue not sinned / we make him a liar

I. John.I. [[1573]

if ... in vs. 1 John 1.8.

1 John 1.8