VOLUME 3

AN ANSWERE VNTO SIR THOMAS MORES DIALOGE

LOCATION
KEY Commentary Side Textual Bibliographic Scriptural

But lat vs se the texte and their glose to gether. Christ saith Luke .xxij. Simon / Simon / sathan seketh you to sifte you as men sifte whete: but I haue prayed for the / that thy faith shall not faile / werfore when thou art come vn to thy selfe agayne strength thy brethern. Now put this wise glose therto and se how they agre to gether. Simon / satan seketh to sift you as whete / but I haue prayd for the / that my mothers faith shall not faile / wherfore when thou art come to thy selfe agayne / acordynge as my prayar hath obtayned for the / that my mothers faith shall not faile / strength thy brethern. How saye ye / is not this a propir texte and well framed to gether? Do ye not thinke that there is as moch witte in the heed of mad colens / as in the braynes of soch expositoures?

But] [1573], but [1531]

Lu. 22. [1531]

Simon ... brethern. Cf. Luke 22.31–32. Answer has "come vn to thy selfe" [C6v], while NT has "converted" (Wallis 179/15;TNT 127C).

Luke 22.31–32

A foolish glose made by M. More.[[1573]

[Hand] [1531]

mad colens. Foxe (5.251) relates how Collins, crazed by his wife's infidelity, held up a dog when the priest elevated the host at Mass. Although non compos mentis, Collins was burnt as a heretic at Smithfield in 1538, cf. PS 3.39. Since "dog" is "God" spelled backwards, his action might indicate a disbelief in Christ's Real Presence in the Eucharist.

so that . . . expositoures. Cf. CWM 8/1.554/8–22.

¶Whether the pope and his secte be Christes church or no

Christes church. In Dialogue Bk. 2, Ch. 1–2, 5, More as Mentor defends the known Catholic Church as the visible church composed of saints and sinners (CWM 6/1.187–95, 206–7).

¶ Whether ... or no. CWM 8/2.576/21. Tyndale's rejection of the medieval church as the true church of Christ is addressed in Confutation, Bk. 5, 6, 7 (cf. CWM 8/1.134/13–14).

That the pope and his spirites be not the church maye this wise be proued. He that hath no faith to be saued thorow Christe / is not of Christes churche. The pope beleueth not to be saued thorow Christe. For he teacheth to trust in holy workes for the remission of sinnes and saluacion: as in the workes of penaunce enioyned / in vowes / in pilgremage / in chastite / in other mens prayars and holy liuynge / in freres and freres cotes / in saintes merites / and the significacions put out / he teacheth to beleue in the dedes of the ceremonies and of the sacramentes ordeyned at the begynnynge to preach vn to vs and to do vs seruice / and not that we shuld beleue in them and serue them. And a thousand such supersticiousnesses setteth he before vs in steade

That . . . proued. Cf. CWM 8/2.577/33–34. Repeated at CWM 8/2.579/19–20.

Pope [1531]

1. [1531]

The Pope & his sect are not the Church of Christ.[[1573]