VOLUME 3

AN ANSWERE VNTO SIR THOMAS MORES DIALOGE

LOCATION
KEY Commentary Side Textual Bibliographic Scriptural

in so moch that they which be most wontte to offer to images and to shewe them / be so colde in offerynge to the pore / that they wyll scace geue them the scrappes which must else be geuen dogges / or their old shone / iff they maye haue new bromes for them.

scace] scarce [1573]

¶Pilgrimages

¶ Pilgrimages. A major theme of Dialogue Bk. 1, Ch. 2–17 (CWM 6/1.5–101). An ample account of the background is found in Jonathan Sumption, Pilgrimage: An Image of Medieval Religion (London: Faber, 1975), in which Ch. 14–15 treat the late-medieval increase of pilgrimages, both to long-revered sanctuaries like Walsingham and Mont-Saint-Michel and to new centers of enthusiastic devotion like Wilsnak, near Wittenberg, with its bleeding host. Lollards attacked pilgrimages as wasteful of time and money, as occasions of lechery, gluttony, and drunkenness away from home and neighbors, and as wrong in localizing Christ or Mary at one place, cf. Hudson 86/122–87/167. Luther's To the Christian Nobility, 1520 (WA 6.447/17–450/21; LW 44.185–89), called for the suppression of pilgrim shrines with their many abuses so people could seek Christ's word and sacrament in their parish churches. Cf. later passages on pilgrimages: [G1v, “pilgrimage and all bodyly exercice”; G4, “He saith . . . their circles”; G6v, “As the miracles . . . se playnly”; M3, “pilgremages”]. The most engaging literary treatment of the theme occurs in Chaucer's Canterbury Tales (c1387—c1400), where the thirty-odd pilgrims to the shrine of Becket represent every class of feudal society . Margery Kempe (c1373-c1439), who dictated the earliest surviving autobiography in English, left a vivid narrative of her three major pilgrimages: to Jerusalem, Assisi, and Rome; to Santiago; to Wilsnak and Aachen. See The Book of Margery Kempe, ed. Sanford Brown Meech and Hope Emily Allen, EETS 212 (London : Oxford UP, 1940).

To speake of pilgrimages / I saye / that a christen man / so that he leaue nothinge vndone at home that he is bounde to doo / is fre to goo whother he will / only aftir the doctrine of the lorde / whose seruaunte he is and not his awne. If he goo and viset the pore / the secke and the presoner / it is well done and a worke that god commaundeth . If he goo to this or that place / to heare a sermon or because his mynd is not quiet at home / or if because his hert is to moch occupied on his worldly businesses bi the reasons of occasions at home / he gett him in to a moare quiett and styll place / where his minde is moare abstracte and pulled from worldly thoughtes it is well done. And in all these places if what soeuer it be / whether liuely preachynge / ceremonie / relique or image stere vpp his herte to god and preach the worde of god and the ensample of oure sauioure Iesus moare in one place then in a nother / that he thither goo / I am content. And yet he bydeth a lorde and the thynges serue him and he not them / Now whether his entent be so or no / his dedes wil testifie / as his vertuouse gouernynge of his housse and louynge demeanoure to warde his neyghboures: yee and gods worde wilbe all waye in his hert and in his mouth & he euery daye perfecter then other.

True Pilgrimage is to walke from place to place ther better to serue God & to helpe my neighbour.[1573]

viset . . . presoner. Cf. Matt. 25.36.

Matthew 25.36

gods . . . mouth. Cf. Rom. 10.8.

Romans 10.8