VOLUME 3

AN ANSWERE VNTO SIR THOMAS MORES DIALOGE

LOCATION
KEY Commentary Side Textual Bibliographic Scriptural

ne / but only a signe and token / that at the repentaunce of the hert / thorow an offeringe to come and for that seedes sake that was promised Abraham / their synnes were forgeuen them.

seedes . . . Abraham. Cf. Gen. 22.18 and 26.4, Gal. 3.16.

Genesis 22.18

Genesis 26.4

Galatians 3.16

no . . . them. Cf. Lev. 9.7. Moses tells Aaron to sacrifice a calf to "make an attonement for the[e] and for the people" (Mombert 322; TOT 161).

Leviticus 9.7

And in like maner the ornamentes and all other ceremonies were eyther an open preachynge or secrett prophisies and not satisfaccions or iustifienges. And thus the workes did serue them and preach vnto them and they not the workes ner put any confidence therin.

Ornamentes [1531]

Workes must serue vs, and not we the workes.[[1573]

¶False worshepynge

¶ False worshepynge. In terminology Tyndale may be echoing Lutheran usage in indicting the pre-Reformation church, especially in numerous position papers drawn up in preparation for the Diet of Augsburg. Cf. Wicks, "Abuses" 257–63 and 274 in reference to Luther's Exhortation to all the Clergy Assembled at Augsburg, 1530 (WA 30/2.345–52; LW 34.52–59).

But what did the children of Israel and the Iewes? They latt the significacions of their ceremonyes goo and lost the meanynge of them and turned them vn to the workes to serue them / sayenge that they were holy workes commaunded of god and the offerars were therby iustified and obtayned forgeuenesse of synnes and therby became good: as the parable of the pharesey and publican declare Luke .xviij. and as it is to se in Paul and thoroute all the Byble: and became captiue to serue and put their trust in that which was nether god ner his worde. And so the better creature agenst nature did serue the worse. Where of all likelyhode god shuld haue accepted their worke by the reason of them / if their hertes had bene right / & not haue accepted their soules for the bloudes sake of a calfe or shepe / for as moch as a man is moch better then a calfe or shepe / as Christ testifieth Matth. xij. For what pleasure shuld god haue in the bloud of calues or in the light of oure candeles? his pleasure is onlye in the hertes of them that loue his commaundementes.

[Hand] [1531] O

workes . . . iustified. For Tyndale Turks, Jews, and papists believe in justification by works and are not counted among the elect because ceremonies alone cannot purge sin from the heart [A5, “And of the lawe . . . vnto god.”; E8, “¶False worshepynge”; I1, “And to poynte . . . false werkes.”; I6, “And a nother . . . theyr hertes.”; K8, “And as for the turkes . . . sworne it.”]. In Matthew (06) he notes how Turks and Jews give alms, but cannot gain salvation because they lack saving faith. For believing that good works make a person righteous, the pope joins the company of the heretical Pelagius (1 John E3v, D8v; Matthew m1v). Tyndale thus contrasts the works of Turks, Jews, and papists with the faith of the elect, who trust in the promise of Christ's blood ([P8, “The turcke . . . Christes bloude”], Matthew 06); their good works are the fruit of faith and love of God [O3v, “he shuld loue . . . sight of god”, Q2, “Whych loue of God . . . R1 . . . consciences of all men.”]

became] become [1573]

parable of the pharesey and publican. Cf. Luke 18.9–14.

Luke 18.9–14

Luc. 18. [1531]

man . . . shepe. Cf. Matt. 12.12.

Matthew 12.12

The Iewes became seruauntes & captiues to theyr workes.[1573]

For . . . calues. Cf. Isa. 1.11.

Isaiah 1.11