VOLUME 3

AN ANSWERE VNTO SIR THOMAS MORES DIALOGE

LOCATION
KEY Commentary Side Textual Bibliographic Scriptural

God did not hate paul / when he persecuted but had layd vpp mercy for him in store / though he was angre wyth hym to scorge hym and to teach him better. Nether were those thynges layd on his backe which he after sofered / to make satisfaccion for his foresinnes / but only to serue hys brethern and to kepe the flesh vnder. Nether did god hate Dauid when he had synned / though he was angre with him. Nether did he after sofre to make satisfaccyon to god for hys olde synnes / but to kepe his flesh vnder and to kepe hym in mekenesse and to be an ensample for oure lernynge.

when . . . better. Cf. Acts 9.1–18, Gal. 1.13–16.

Acts 9.1–18

Galatians 1.13–16

2 Corinthians 12.7

Colossians 1.24

serue hys brethern. Cf. Col. 1.24; kepe the flesh vnder. Cf. 2 Cor. 12.7.

Dauid . . . synned. Cf. 2 Sam. 11–12.1–25.

2 Samuel 11–12.1–25

The new life doeth tame the flesh and serue hyr neyboure. [1531]

iiij.

iiij.] The iiij. Chapter. [1573]

In the fourth saith he if the church were an vnknowen companie / how shuld the infydeles / yf they longed for the faith / come therby? O whother wandereth a fleshly minde / as though we first sought out god. Nay / God knoweth his and seketh them out and sendeth his mesingers vnto them and geueth them an hert to vnderstonde. Dyd the hethen or any nacyon seke chryste? Nay / christ sought them and sent hys appostles vnto them. As thou seyst in the storyes from the begynnynge of the worlde and as the parables and similitudes of the gospell declare.

if . . . therby. Cf. CWM 6/1.200/29–34.

as . . . god. Cf. 1 John 4.10.

1 John 4.10

God seketh vs and we not hym. [1531]

christ . . . vnto them. Cf. Matt. 28.19, Mark 16.15, Luke 24.47.

Matt. 28.19, Mark 16.15, Luke 24.47

storyes . . . declare. For God's mercy to Adam and Eve after the Fall, cf. Gen. 3.9–24. For the liberation of a remnant from the Babylonian captivity, cf. Ezek. 34.11. For the extension of Yahweh's favor to the Gentiles, cf. the three foreign women in the genealogy of Jesus: the Canaanite Rahab, cf. Josh. 2.1–21; the Moabite Ruth, cf. Ruth 1.4; the Hittite Bathsheba, cf. 2 Sam. 11.3. God's quest for the lost soul is depicted in the parables of the lost sheep and the lost coin, cf. Luke 15.4–6, 8–9.

Genesis 3.9–24

Joshua 2.1–21

Ruth 1.4

2 Samuel 11.3

Ezekiel 34.11

Luke 15.4–6

Luke 15.8–9

And when he saith / he neuer founde ner herd of any of vs / but that he wold forswere to saue his life. Answere / the moare wrath of god will light on them / that so cruelly delite to torment them and so craftely to begyle the weake. Neuer thelesse yet it is vntrue. For he hath hearde of sir Thomas hitton whom the bisshopes of Rochester and caunterbury slew at maydstone and of many that sofered in braband holland and at colen and in all

More a lying papist.[1573]

he neuer . . . life. Cf. CWM 6/1.201/21–22.

vntrue] [1573], vntue [1531]

sir Thomas hitton. To counter Dialogue's claim that reformers would not die for their beliefs (cf. CWM 6/1.201/20–22), Tyndale asserts Hitton's perseverance unto death (Prelates K6). Confutation calls Hitton "the dyuyls stynkyng martyr" (CWM 8/1.17/1), and Apology opposes Hitton's execution near Canterbury to Becket's martyrdom in Canterbury (CWM 9.355). Foxe briefly summarizes Hitton's imprisonment and death at Maidstone in 1530 (4.619) and his interrogations by Warham and Fisher (8.712–15). Cf. [commentary notes to I6v, “heretikes . . . abiure”; M4, “no iudge . . . inconuenientes”; R5v, “ye deliuer . . . asshes”].

Sir Thomas hitton [1531]

caunterbury. William Warham (c1456–1532) was Lord Chancellor (1504–15) until he was replaced by Wolsey, and Archbishop of Canterbury (1503–32) until his death. On 15 May 1532, the higher clergy of the Archdiocese of Canterbury accepted the king's authority to license the legislative acts of the English Church, and the next day, Warham as Primate presented the document of submission to Henry. Later the same day, More resigned from the Chancellorship (NCE 14.811; OER 4.257–58). In the Obedience, Tyndale accuses Warham of wanting to keep the NT as the secret of priests and a mystery to layfolk (K2v). Here, Tyndale condemns Warham and Fisher for their part in burning Thomas Hitton alive for importing a Tyndale NT in 1529.

in braband. A reference to the vigorous imperial prosecution of Lutherans in. the Spanish Netherlands. The first victims were two Antwerp Augustinian friars, Heinrich Voes and Johann van Esch, who were burned in the Great Square of Brussels on 1 July 1523. Luther was deeply moved by news of their deaths and composed both an open letter of encouragement to the surviving reformers in the Low Countries, Ein Brief an die Christen im Niederland (WA 12.77–80; not in LW), and a ballad (WA 35.411–15; not in LW). Erasmus comments on this event in Ep. 1384, To Huldrych Zwingli, Basel, 31 August [1523] (Allen 5.327/4–6; CWE 10.81/5–7). He refers to the execution of these two friars and of Louis de Berquin in April 1529 in Ep. 2188, To Charles Utenhove, Freiburg, 1 July 1529 (Allen 8.210/11–211/31; not yet in CWE).

at colen. The Cologne faculty of theology had condemned numerous propositions found in Luther's works even before the papal bull Exsurge Domine. In 1529 a quickly conducted heresy trial resulted in the burning of the Lutherans Adolph Clarenbach and Peter Fliesteden.