VOLUME 3

AN ANSWERE VNTO SIR THOMAS MORES DIALOGE

LOCATION
KEY Commentary Side Textual Bibliographic Scriptural

ate doute also and a perelouse case if it were left out. For ether it was done to slake the hete of the wine or put to after / as a ceremonie / to signifie that as the water is chaunged in to wine / so are we chaunged thorow faith as it were in to christe and are one with him / how be it all is to their awne shame / that ought shuld be done or vsed amonge vs christen / where of noman wist the meaninge. For if I vnderstonde not the meaninge / it helpeth me not .1. corin. xiiij. and as experience teacheth. But if oure sheperdes had bene as wel willynge to fede as to shere / we had neded no soch dispicience / ner they to haue burnt so many as they haue.

meaninge] ed., meanige [1531], meaning [1573]

For ... 1 corin. xiiij. Cf. 1 Cor. 14.2–3, CWM 8/1.161/29–30.

] 1 Corinthians

1. Cori. 14. [1531]

sheperdes . . . shere. Cf. Ezek. 34.2–3.

] Ezekiel

A greate . . . haue. Cf. CWM 8/1.318/11–20.

And as for that he allegeth out of the epistle of Iames for the iustifienge of workes. I haue answered in the Mammon agenst which he can not hisse / and will speake moare in the .iiij. boke.

Iustification of workes.[1573]

Iames . . . workes. Cf. Jas. 2.24 and CWM 6/1.149/7.

] James

Mammon. Tyndale assumed public responsibility for his writings when he put his name at the head of the preface of Mammon (May 1528). He refers to Mammon in Obedience (I2v, Q3v), the afterword to Genesis (TOT 82) and Answer (here and [Q5, “it is answered him in the mammon”]). For Tyndale's gradual acknowledgment of authorship, see O'Donnell, "Editing the Independent Works of William Tyndale," in Editing Texts From the Age of Erasmus (U of Toronto P, 1996) 49–70.

And as for the Saboth / agreate mater / we be lordes ouer the saboth and maye yet chaunge it in to the monedaye or any other daye / as we se nede / or maye make euery tenth daye holy daye only if we se a cause why / we maye make .ij. euery weke / if it were expedient & one not ynough to teach the people. Nether was there any cause to chaunge it from the saterdaye then to put difference betwene vs and the Iewes and lest we shuld become seruauntes vn to the daye aftir their supersticion. Nether neded we any holydaye at all / if the people might be taught with out it.

Saboth [1531]

or] or or [1573]

holy daye] [1573], holy dage [1531]

holy daye. 1531's "dage" could be a mispelling by the Flemish compositor.

The Saboth day & holy dayes are made for vs & not we for them.[1573]

And as for . . . with out it. Cf. CWM 6/1.149/21–28; quoted exactly by CWM 8/1.321/6–14. In the OT the Sabbath is characterized by abstention from work (Exod. 20.8), a festive spirit (Isa. 58.13), and religious instruction (Lev. 23.3). The early church moved the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday to commemorate Christ's Resurrection. Tyndale's freedom regarding which day to observe the Sabbath is based on Col. 2.16, Rom. 14.5 (NCE 12.778–82; OER 3.459–60). Between 1527 and c1540, Anabaptists in Silesia and Moravia celebrated the Lord's Day on Saturday. This development prompted Luther to write Against the Sabbatarians in 1538 (WA 50.312–37; LW 47.65–98).

] Exodus

] Leviticus

] Isaiah

] Romans

] Colossians

And when he axeth by what scripture we know that a woman maye christen. I answere / if baptim be so necessary as they make it / then

Whi wemen baptise [1531]

by ... christen. For baptism by women, cf. CWM 6/1.149/28–30, 8/1.307/31–32.