VOLUME 3

AN ANSWERE VNTO SIR THOMAS MORES DIALOGE

LOCATION
KEY Commentary Side Textual Bibliographic Scriptural

nother in the waye of christ. And god they serue in the spirite only / in loue / hope faith and dreade.

But . . . dreade. The role ascribed to the law sharply distinguishes Tyndale's account of justification from that of Luther, for whom saving faith is exclusively focused on God's redemptive mercy in Christ toward those whom the law has prepared by convicting them of sin. In justification, for Luther, God relates to a believer who has been carried beyond the demands of the law. [This note refers to text which also appears on I2 and I2v.]

And he . . . dreade. Compare Luther's account of the believer's willing service of others without thought of recompense : "to serve, help, and deal with the neighbor as he sees that God through Christ has dealt with him and still deals with him," Freedom of a Christian, 1520 (WA 7.35/25–27; LW 31.366).

When the greate multitude that be called and not chosen / Caim / Ismael / Esau and carnall Israel that serue God night and daye with bodyly seruice and holy workes soch as they were wont to serue their Idoles with all / behold litle flocke that they come not forth in the seruice of god / they rore out / where art thou? whi comest thou not forth & takest holy watere? wherfore saith litle flocke. To put awaye thy sinnes. Nay brethern / God forbid that ye shuld so thinke / Christes bloud only washeth awaye the synnes of all that repent and beleue. Fire / salt / water / bred / oyle be bodyly thynges / geuen vn to man for his necessite and to helpe his brother with / & god that is a spirite can not be serued therwith. Nether can soch thinges enter in to the soule to purge hir. For gods worde only is hir purgacion. No saye they / are not soch thinges halowed. And saye we not in the halowenge of them that whosoeuer is sprinkled with the water or eateth of the bred / shall receaue health of soule and body? Sir the blessynges promised vnto Abraham for all nacions are in christ / and out of his bloud we must fett them / and his word is the breed / salt and water of oure soules. God hath geuen you no power to geue thorow youre charmes soch vertue vn to vnsensible creatures / which he hath halowed him selfe and made them all cleane (for the bodyly vse of them that beleue) thorow his worde of promese and permission and oure thankes geuinge. God saith / if thou beleue saynt Ihons Gospell / thou shalt be saued / and not for the beringe of it aboute the with so many crosses /

A pretye Antithesis betwen the Popes Churche & Christes litle flocke.[1573]

greate . . . chosen. Cf. Matt. 22.14.

] Matthew

] Jeremiah

litle] the little [1573]

] Jeremiah

[Hand] [1531]

bred /] bread, & [1573]

Fire/salt/water/bred/oyle. Little Flock opposes the multitude 's claim that objects have spiritual potency by appealing to the sole saving power of Christ's blood laid hold of by faith in his word. The beliefs of the multitude rest on the church's myriad prayers of blessing over objects, which are studied panoramically in A. Franz, Die kirchlichen Benediktionen im Mittlealter, 2 vol. (Freiburg: Herder, 1909).

god ... therwith. Cf. John 4.24.

] John

The Popish church aunswereth.[1573]

The litle flocke.[1573]

blessynges . . . nacions. Cf. Gen. 18.18, Gal. 3.16.

] Genesis

] Galatians