|
KEY Commentary Side Textual Bibliographic Scriptural
|
ther sustinaunce be gotten. Then thou must interpret soch
cases excepte / though thou madest no mencion of them / at
the makinge of thi vow. Some man wold saye / other shifte
might be made: what then? If other drinke as whote as wine
& of the same operacion / and other meate of the same
power and vertue as flesh is / must be had / whi shuldest
thou forswere wine or fleshe / seinge it is now no lenger for
the taminge of thy bodi. And so forth of al
wother / as I haue aboue declared.
|
|
And when he bringeth in the apostles / marters /
confessoures and .xv. hundred yeres / it is cleane
contrary. For they had no soch false imaginacion of
chastite or of any other worke: but they vsed it to serue
their neyboure and to avoyde trouble in time of persecucion
and to be eased of that burthen that was to heuy for their weake shulders and not to compell god to thanke them for the
liberte for which they be bound to thanke him.
|
apostles . . .
yeres. Cf. CWM 6/1.376/1–3.
avoyde . . .
persecucion. Cf. 1 Cor. 7.26–27.
Marten . . .
thanke him. Tyndale takes up a series of allegations from Dialogue, Bk. 4, Ch. 7–9, which have little
thematic unity. (JW)
|
x.
|
|
In the tenth he inveyeth and rayleth agenst that which
nether he ner any fleshly mynded papiste can vnderstonde /
as they haue no
power to consent vnto the lawes of god. Which
herein appereth /
that they compell their brethern which be as
good as they to do & beleue what they lust and not what
god commaundeth. He affirmeth that marten saith how that we
do no synne oure selues wyth oure awne wylle / but that god
synneth in vs and vseth vs as a deed instrument and forseth
vs ther vn to and damneth vs / not for oure awne deedes but
for hys / and for hys awne pleasure / as he compelleth vn to
synne for hys pleasure or rather he for hys pleasure synneth
in vs. I saye / that a man synneth voluntaryly.
|
he inveyeth and
rayleth. More does indeed use vehement language against
Luther's teaching that God's universal causality includes even sin: "And
thus these wretched heretyques wyth this blasphemouse heresye alone /
lay more vylaynous rebuke to the greate maieste of god / than euer eny
one rybaulde layed vnto a nother" (CWM 6/1.377/6–9). Fisher also defends
free will vigorously , especially in Art. 36 of his Assertionis Lutheranae confutatio, 1522, cf.
Surtz 227–34.
how . . . synneth
in vs. Cf. CWM 6/1.377/3–6.
vseth ... synne for
hys pleasure. Cf. CWM 6/1.377/24–28.
|