Ulrich Stuller was born around 1788 in Maryland to Henry Stuller. He married Nancy Ann Steinbaugh around 1834, and they had at least five children: Henry, born around 1835; Eminella, born around 1840; George, born around 1842; Ephraim, born around 1846; and Andrew, born around 1848. The family moved to Todd, Pennsylvania, in the late 1830s. Stuller worked as a shoemaker, and he owned $150 of real estate in 1850. They moved to Huntingdon, Pennsylvania, in the 1850s. Stuller died sometime after 1865.