Sarah Melissa Shaeffer (Clark) was born on July 28, 1861, in Fairfield County, Ohio, to Emanuel and Lucy Clark. She was raised, however, by Gilbert and Mary Shaeffer, and she took their last name. She married Jethro Ayers Hatch on May 26, 1881, and they had at least two children: Darwin, born around 1883; and Hazel, born around 1886. They lived in Kentland, Indiana, and her husband worked as a doctor. They moved to Victoria, Texas, around 1907, and her husband died there on August 3, 1912. She returned to Kentland in the 1910s. She applied for a widow’s pension in August 1912 and eventually secured one. She died of “coronary thrombosis” in Knox, Indiana, on December 9, 1947.